Your message has been sent successfully! I'll be in touch soon.

So sorry; there was an error submitting the form. Please try again!

I’m Hispano-Roman with Green Eyes and not a PDN Judge

And I’m married to a white man with blue eyes. Is that diversity? Can we be… trusted? What happened to the We Are All One mantra? It seems the more we try to achieve world unity, the more we become scrutinized for being, well, whatever we happen to be!

Here is how this topic comes around to photography. I received my June issue of Photo District News the other day. All 80 pages. It’s the “Careers & Self-Promotion” Issue. One article is titled, “Eye-Catching Promos Under $3,000.” I should hope they are blinding the editor for that price! Despite big promises on the cover, the issue had little new information given the sophistication of their audience. When I tossed it on top of my huge stack of back issues, I wondered why I should bother to renew my subscription.

Yesterday, I received a bulk-mail renewal order form with a canned message from Publisher Lauren Wendle. Her headline reads: “It’s not a pretty picture.” That is, if I don’t renew NOW. No, I guess it isn’t!

The topper came today when I read on the duckrabbit blog that there is a new contest that has to do with PDN. You can win $1000! How? It seems that a recent panel of PDN Judges (24 and I know a few), are all white!

Stan Banos claims on his blog here that this is an example of “passive racism” and an outrageous slur on the photographic industry. Therefore, duckrabbit is offering a cool 1K to anyone who can prove Stan wrong by providing the best answer to the question: “What possible, plausible excuse could exist for PDN to select an all white jury from a publication of such influence?”

PDN, dying on the vine, has to play with their friends and advertisers, who I guess happen to be white. I really hope someone wins that money!

Update as of June 9, 2009: There is a statement issued by PDN on this issue here: PDNPulse on Lack of Diversity…

by Jain

show hide 6 comments

Link to this post Email a friend

Michael Lustbader - Obviously, there are no black photographers... (joke). The only counter to "passive racism" is attention. Constant, immediate, and LOUD. For a commercial media publication to be so unconscious is laughable. Good for you for putting it on your blog! PDN in particular has become like an ingrown toenail. When the only opinions you solicit are opinions you already know...June 7, 2009 - 6:29 am

Hoiyin Ip - Interesting topic. What do you think of sexism in the industry?June 8, 2009 - 9:41 am

Jain - Michael, I couldn't agree more and PDN only needed to say, "Gee we messed up, we're sorry," and this would not have been a big issue. I think they have that responsibility at least. Rob Haggart has an interesting discussion going about this topic on his blog: A Photo Editor. http://www.aphotoeditor.com/2009/06/06/pdns-all-white-photo-contest-jury/ June 8, 2009 - 11:25 am

Jain - Hoiyin, I have seen women recognized more and more since I got into the business. Still, there are many targeted programs tagged, "Women in Photography" and I've never seen "Men in Photography." I haven't heard of any type of unequal pay for women shooters, editors or agents, but I'm sure there are cases.June 8, 2009 - 11:27 am

ellenherbert@roadrunner.com - so...did you renew your subscription?June 8, 2009 - 7:25 pm

Jain - Hello, Ellen! That's a good question. This one-woman-Portuguese-American jury is still out!June 9, 2009 - 8:11 am

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*